That's Totally You Review: Is This the Best Icebreaker Game for Groups?

Finding an icebreaker game that actually gets people talking—without awkward silences—is a challenge. That's Totally You, a party game from Big Potato Games, promises to reveal what your friends really think of you through fun, fast-paced rounds. But does it deliver? In this That's Totally You review, we'll break down the gameplay, group dynamics, and whether it's worth adding to your collection.

Whether you're hosting a dinner party, a team-building event, or a casual get-together, the right icebreaker can set the tone. That's Totally You aims to be that game, blending humor with lighthearted judgment. Let's see if it lives up to the hype.

What Is That's Totally You?

That's Totally You is a party game where players guess how others would describe them. Each round, one player is the 'subject,' and everyone else picks a descriptor card that they think best fits that person. The subject then tries to guess which cards were chosen for them. It's a mix of self-perception and social insight, often leading to hilarious revelations.

The game is designed for 4–8 players and takes about 20–30 minutes per session. It comes with over 200 descriptor cards, covering traits like 'would cry at a cat food commercial' or 'secretly a competitive eater.' The simplicity makes it easy to teach, and the humor keeps energy high. Unlike some icebreaker games that feel forced, That's Totally You leans into playful teasing.

• Best for groups of 4–8 players who already know each other moderately well.
• Rounds are quick—perfect for keeping momentum during a party.

Gameplay and Mechanics

The core loop is straightforward: one player is the 'subject.' Everyone else secretly selects a descriptor card they think applies to the subject. The subject then guesses which cards were chosen, earning points for correct guesses. The game encourages players to be honest but kind—the goal is laughter, not embarrassment.

What sets That's Totally You apart from other icebreaker games is its focus on positive or quirky traits rather than negative ones. Cards are designed to be amusing but not mean-spirited. This makes it a safe choice for mixed company, including coworkers or new friends. The game also includes blank cards so you can write your own descriptors, adding a personal touch.

• No reading required beyond short phrases—great for quick rounds.
• Blank cards let you customize for your specific group.

Who Is That's Totally You For?

That's Totally You shines with groups that already have some rapport. If you're looking for an icebreaker for complete strangers, you might need a warmer-up round first. But for friends, family, or colleagues who know each other's quirks, it's a hit. The game works well at parties, game nights, or even as a team-building activity.

Compared to other Big Potato Games like 'Don't Get Got' (a hidden-mission game) or 'Herd Mentality' (a herd-thinking game), That's Totally You is more about personal connection than competition. It's less about winning and more about sharing laughs. If your group enjoys games like 'What's the Best Thing' or 'scrawl-105917">Scrawl,' this will likely be a good fit.

• Ideal for groups of 4–8; smaller groups can still play but may have fewer card options.
• Not recommended for very serious or easily offended groups—humor is central.

Pros and Cons

Pros: The game is easy to learn, quick to play, and generates genuine laughs. The cards are well-written and avoid offensive content. The blank cards add replayability. It's also compact—easy to bring to parties or trips.

Cons: The game relies heavily on players knowing each other. With strangers, it can fall flat. Also, after several plays, you might see repeat descriptors. Some players may find the guessing mechanic less engaging than more active party games. If your group prefers high-energy games like 'Block Party' or 'I'm Gonna Risk It,' this might feel too slow.

• Consider your group's dynamic before buying—it's best for established friend groups.
• If you want a more active icebreaker, look into 'You Can't Say Umm' for a speaking challenge.

That's Totally You Worth Buying?

So, is That's Totally You worth buying? If you regularly host gatherings with friends who enjoy lighthearted humor and self-reflection, yes. It's a solid addition to any party game collection, especially if you already own more chaotic games and want something conversational. The price point is typical for Big Potato Games—around $20–25—making it an affordable option.

However, if your group is large (8+), you might find the player limit restrictive. For bigger groups, consider 'Herd Mentality' which accommodates up to 20 players. Also, if you prefer games with more strategy or physical activity, this may not be your first choice. Ultimately, That's Totally You delivers on its promise as an icebreaker, but it's not for every occasion.

• Best for small to medium groups that enjoy knowing each other's quirks.
• Pairs well with other party games like 'P For Pizza' for a varied game night.

That's Totally You is a charming, low-stakes icebreaker that succeeds when played with the right crowd. It's easy to teach, quick to play, and sparks conversations that go beyond surface-level small talk. While it may not suit every group or every mood, for those looking to add a personal, humorous touch to their game night, it's a worthy pick. If you're on the fence, consider your group's familiarity with each other—and if they're ready to be lovingly roasted, this game will deliver.